It's natural to want to protect yourself from heartbreak, but sometimes we can overanalyze our partner's behavior or second-guess our own instincts. How do you know if you're spotting a genuine red flag, overthinking something harmless, or just holding your partner to impossibly high standards? Let's break it down.
What Is a Red Flag?
A "red flag" is a warning sign that something in the relationship might not be healthy. It’s not about one-off mistakes or small quirks—it’s about patterns of behavior that signal deeper issues. Red flags are behaviors that could lead to toxic dynamics, emotional harm, or even abuse if left unchecked.
Some common red flags include:
Controlling Behavior: If your partner tries to control what you wear, where you go, or who you see, it's a significant red flag. This behavior indicates a lack of respect for your autonomy and can escalate into more serious issues2.
Dishonesty and Gaslighting: Frequent lying or manipulation can erode trust and create a toxic environment. Gaslighting, in particular, is a form of emotional abuse that makes you question your own perceptions, and unfortunately, it can be very subtle14.
Emotional or Physical Abuse: Any form of abuse, whether emotional, mental, or physical, is a clear red flag. It indicates a deep disregard for your well-being and safety24.
Disrespect for Boundaries: If your partner consistently disregards your boundaries or makes you feel uncomfortable by pushing you to do things you're not ready for, it's a sign of disrespect and potential manipulation37.
Red flags aren’t always obvious at first. Sometimes they show up subtly and grow over time, which is why it’s important to stay mindful of patterns.
What Does Overthinking Look Like?
On the flip side, overthinking is when we read too much into situations that don’t actually warrant concern. It’s easy to fall into this trap when you’ve been hurt before or are naturally anxious about relationships. Overthinking often comes from a place of fear—fear of being vulnerable, fear of rejection, or fear of making the wrong choice.
Signs that you might be overthinking include:
Overanalyzing every word and action: You dissect text messages like they’re clues in a mystery novel.
Jumping to conclusions: You assume the worst without any real evidence.
Fixating on small details: You get hung up on things like how long it took them to reply to your text.
Feeling anxious without cause: You worry about things going wrong even when everything seems fine.
Struggling to trust: You constantly doubt your partner’s intentions even though they’ve given no reason for suspicion.
Overthinking can create problems where there aren’t any and make it harder for you to enjoy the relationship.
Are Your Standards Too High?
Another layer to this conversation is understanding whether your expectations are realistic. Having high standards isn’t a bad thing—it’s important to know what you want and deserve in a relationship—but sometimes we can set the bar so high that no one can meet it.
For example:
Expecting your partner to always say the exact right thing at the exact right time? Unrealistic.
Expecting your partner to treat you with respect and kindness? Totally fair.
It’s all about balance. Healthy standards focus on core values like trust, communication, and compatibility—not superficial details like how many times they text you in a day.
Red Flag vs. No Red Flag
Let’s look at two examples of text conversations to see how this plays out in real life.
Example: A Genuine Red Flag
You: Hey, I’m going out with some friends tonight.
Partner: Oh really? Who are you going with?
You: It’s just a casual night out. Why do you want to know?
Partner: Because I want to know if I should be worried. Now it feels like you're hiding something since you aren't telling me.
You: That feels a bit controlling...
Partner: Oh really? It feels controlling that you are acting weird about who you are going out with. Text me when you get there.
This conversation shows controlling behavior and emotional manipulation—two major red flags. Your partner is demanding information in a way that feels invasive and dismisses your feelings when you try to express discomfort (gaslighting).
Example: Not a Red Flag
You: Hey, I’m going out with some friends tonight.
Partner: Oh really? Who are you going with?
You: It’s just a casual night out. Why do you want to know?
Partner: Was just wondering... Have fun!
Partner: Feel free to text me when you get there.
This exchange is healthy and caring. Your partner is showing interest in your plans without being controlling and asking for a check-in because they care about your safety—not because they don’t trust you.
If you're prone to overthinking, though, you might start wondering:
Why did they ask who I’m going with? Do they not trust me? Does this mean they are controlling me??
Do they think Alex and Jamie are bad influences? Who do they think they are judging my friends??
Why didn’t they say “have fun” with more emojis? Are they being selfish and only thinking of themselves?
Why did they only say "Oh really?" instead of something more enthusiastic? Are they not happy for me? Are they mad at me? I'm feeling controlled right now....
See how quickly overthinking can turn something innocent into unnecessary anxiety that can consume you all evening with your friends?
How to Tell the Difference
So how can you figure out whether something is a red flag or just harmless behavior? Here are some tips:
1. Look for Patterns
One isolated incident doesn’t usually mean much—it’s patterns that matter. If someone occasionally says something thoughtless but generally treats you well, it’s probably not a red flag. But if they consistently dismiss your feelings or criticize you, that’s worth addressing.
2. Trust Your Gut
Your intuition is powerful—listen to it! If something feels off, take some time to reflect on why. Are there specific behaviors making you uncomfortable? Or could it be your own fears creeping in? Somatic therapy can really help you sort all this out, so feel free to reach out to schedule a session if needed!
3. Talk It Out
Communication is key in any relationship. If something bothers you, bring it up calmly and directly with your partner. Their response will tell you a lot—are they open and understanding, or defensive and dismissive? If you are afraid to bring up a concern, that is a sign that fear is controlling your behavior. The question is, is the fear a genuine concern in THIS relationship, or is the fear and old subconscious pattern inserting itself into your relationship. If needed, this is also something that I can help you discern in a counseling session.
How to Stop Overthinking
If overthinking has become a habit for you, here are some strategies to help:
Pause before reacting: When something triggers anxiety, take a step back before jumping to conclusions.
Focus on facts: Ask yourself what evidence supports your worries—and what evidence contradicts them.
Practice mindfulness: Stay present instead of getting lost in “what if” scenarios.
Set boundaries with yourself: Limit how much time and energy you spend analyzing things that don’t actually matter.
Remind yourself of the good stuff: Focus on the positive aspects of your relationship instead of fixating on potential problems.
When High Standards Are Healthy
Having high standards isn’t about being picky—it’s about knowing what kind of relationship will make you happy and fulfilled. Healthy standards include:
Expecting mutual respect
Wanting open communication
Valuing emotional compatibility
Prioritizing honesty and trust
Seeking shared goals and values
These are non-negotiables that help build strong relationships—and there’s nothing wrong with holding out for them!
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, relationships require both self-awareness and trust—trust in yourself and trust in your partner. It’s okay (and smart!) to keep an eye out for red flags, but don’t let fear or over-analysis rob you of joy in the moment. If you're struggling to sort through these feelings on your own, consider reaching out for support to help guide you through the process. Remember—you deserve love that feels safe, supportive, and fulfilling!
Commentaires